Allan Saint-Maximin 'overpriced at £50m' as Newcastle United details emerge - pundit

Allan Saint-Maximin 'overpriced at £50m' as Newcastle United details emerge - pundit

Connor Humm

A broadcast journalism masters graduate from Salford University, Connor has worked for Breaking Media since April 2024. He is Social Media Director and responsible for overseeing Football Insider's Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Threads and WhatsApp pages. Connor bleeds red-and-white, and is an avid Arsenal supporter who covered the club's 2025 pre-season Asia tour for Football Insider's social team.

Published on

Allan Saint-Maximin's transfer from Newcastle United to Al-Ahli is a "grey area" in football business.

Speaking exclusively to Football Insider, former Tottenham and Aston Villa defender Alan Hutton said if Newcastle had demanded £50million for Saint-Maximin it would have raised eyebrows.

According to The Athletic (22 July), a number of Premier League clubs are planning to raise concerns with the league over the deal which is taking place between two teams under the same majority ownership - Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund.

The league regulations state that any transfer over £1m is checked to ensure it does not "exceed market value" whilst other clubs are worried that the PIF link is being used to inflate the winger's fee and help Newcastle with financial fair play rules.

The 26-year-old has confirmed his departure from St James' Park as he prepares to make a £30m move to the Saudi Pro League side.

Hutton suggested that as long as the final fee is not way above Saint-Maximin's value, there shouldn't be a big problem.

"It is an interesting one and there will be a lot of eyes on the situation," he told Football Insider.

"It all comes down to the valuation of the player and teams trying to balance their books.

"If we are sitting and saying a Saudi team would pay £50m for him, that would be overpriced and I think everybody from the outside looking in can see that.

"He is a great footballer, £20m is probably about right for a player of his quality but it is definitely a grey area."

www.footballinsider247.com