Ex-Fifa official issues Celtic injustice claim as controversial Reo Hatate footage emerges

Ex-Fifa official issues Celtic injustice claim as controversial Reo Hatate footage emerges

Keith Hackett

Refereeing Consultant AUTHORITY Former FIFA Referee; Head of PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited). FOCUS Laws of the Game, VAR implementation, officiating performance, and PGMOL policy. THE AUDIT Keith utilises Statscore’s Officiating Telemetry, including Deep-Data Metrics like Incident Accuracy Rates, VAR Intervention Latency, and Official Positional Efficiency. He provides technical refereeing analysis to reveal the regulatory reality behind match-defining decisions.

Published on

The referee was right not to award Celtic a penalty for Anthony Stewart's challenge on Reo Hatate as they beat Aberdeen 2-0 on Sunday (31 July), according to Keith Hackett.

Speaking exclusively to Football Insider, the ex-Fifa and Premier League referee insisted Stewart fell into Hatate and there was not enough contact for a spot-kick to be awarded.

As shown on Sportscene, the pair went for a loose ball just inside the penalty area and Hatate went down under Stewart's challenge after getting a weak shot away.

Referee Nick Walsh, who was well placed on the edge of the penalty area, waved away Celtic's appeals and the game continued.

"I didn't see this as a penalty kick, to be honest," Hackett said after analysing the footage with Football Insider correspondent Connor Whitley.

"It would have been a very harsh call. On that clip that I saw, the referee is, again, well positioned.

"The defender falls into him. He's fallen, from the knee down he's on the deck and can't turn.

"For me, I don't think that's sufficient. I go with the referee.

"Players do fall down, fall over, get pushed and all that goes with it. In my opinion, that doesn't warrant a penalty kick.

"He falls over. I'm going with the referee."

Celtic

The Hoops were winning 1-0 at the time of the incident before Jota scored a stunning goal to double their lead.

They are now top of the Scottish Premiership and are next in action at the weekend (6 August) when they visit Ross County.

www.footballinsider247.com