Pundit fumes over 'nonsensical' Luiz decision at Aston Villa

Pundit fumes over 'nonsensical' Luiz decision at Aston Villa

Paul Robinson

Paul Robinson is a former England goalkeeper who played in the Premier League for Tottenham Hotspur, Leeds United Blackburn Rovers and Burnley. Paul is a former England international, earning 41 caps between 2003 and 2007. He joined Football Insider in 2020 and is a regular at Premier League matches and also often hops on a plane to cover the Saudi Pro League as well as Serie A.

Published on

Paul Robinson is baffled by referee Michael Oliver denying Leicester City a penalty against Aston Villa on Sunday.

Speaking exclusively to Football Insider, the ex-Tottenham and England goalkeeper called the decision "nonsensical" and could not understand why it was not flagged up by VAR.

As shown on BBC Match of the Day (5 December), Villa midfielder Douglas Luiz appeared to stand on Keirnan Dewsbury-Hall's foot in the penalty area.

The incident would prove a decisive moment in the match with Steven Gerrard's side eventual 2-1 winners over the Foxes.

It was one of two controversial moments at Villa Park on Sunday.

Oliver, 36, also ruled out a goal for Jacob Ramsey after he deemed Leicester goalkeeper Kasper Schmeichel to be in control of the ball.

Robinson claimed the decisions probably evened themselves out in the end.

"I'm very surprised the Luiz challenge didn't go to VAR," he told Football Insider's Dylan Childs.

"When you look at that and the Ramsey goal that was disallowed. They probably evened themselves out but that shouldn't be how it works.

"Luiz stood on his foot a bit like how Fred stood on David de Gea's foot.

"If you look at that you wonder what the guidelines for clear and obvious are. It makes no sense to me."

Aston Villa

Aston Villa's win was Gerrard's third in four games since joining the club.

The Claret and Blue sit 10th in the Premier League table.

www.footballinsider247.com