2. Sergio Aguero
Games v Newcastle: 12 – Goals: 14 – Assists: 3
Unfortunately for Newcastle, unlike the previous names on this list, Aguero is still playing, and although he has had his injury problems in the past, he always finds a way to net another couple against them.
Whatever he might have against the Toon Army, with an evident personal vendetta against the club, they might want to find out and fix things immediately, for he always ups his game whenever the Magpies are around.
He has only failed to net against Newcastle in three matches, even scoring when making seven minute cameos, and his name is one which will make the Newcastle faithful shudder in fear.
The Argentine star’s top highlight is without a doubt the five goals he scored in the 6-1 drubbing back in 2015, running riot against Steve McLaren’s men – who had actually taken the lead at the Etihad Stadium.
His most recent outing saw him net a hat trick back in January 2018 – and Newcastle fans will be hoping they find a way to stop him come the 2018/19 campaign.
Click below for the number one tormentor of Newcastle…